The House of Representatives recently passed a Bill (HR 4213) that would raise taxes on many small business owners who are treated as a sub-chapter S corporation for tax purposes. It is disheartening that the US House of Representatives wants to increase taxes on so many small business owners. HR4213, is now under consideration by the US Senate.
Below is a letter that we have sent to our clients who own sub-chapter S corporations:
Dear Client,
The US House of Representatives passed a bill (HR4213) which extends many of the Bush tax cuts. This bill has several revenue offsets; one of which could be particular damaging to many of our clients.
While HR 4213 has not yet passed the US Senate; it is expected to pass a similar but different bill. These changes will be resolved in a Conference Committee. President Obama is expected to sign the bill once it is passed by both the House and Senate.
HR 4213 as written in the House will increase taxes on a large number of small businesses that are treated as a sub-chapter S corporation for tax purposes. Sub-chapter S corporations were first available in 1958. In 2007, almost four million S corporation tax returns were filed with the IRS; of those the average entity had an average of 1.7 shareholders. It is likely that close to 4.5 million S corporation tax returns will be filed with the IRS in 2011.
The new law proposes increasing taxes on certain sub-chapter S corporations as of January 1st, 2011. Under current law owners of sub-chapter S corporations are required to pay themselves a reasonable salary. Currently S corporation owners pay self employment taxes (social security and Medicare) on their salary only. Additionally owners pay income tax on their salaries and on their remaining profits earned each year.
The new law would require certain S corporation owners to pay self employment taxes on all income earned from their S corporations. This is a major change in the current law and would be a large tax increase for certain owners of S corporations.
The House version would affect the following S corporations:
(1) It only effects S corporations that are engaged in a professional service business if the principal asset of the business is the reputation and skill of three or fewer employees.
(2) A professional service business is defined as a trade or business, substantially all of the activities of which involve providing services in the field of health, law, lobbying, engineering, architecture, accounting, actuarial science, performing arts, consulting, athletics, investment advice or management, or brokerage services.
This law is currently very vague and if enacted will have to be more strictly defined by the IRS.
Based on a review of our clients this law will affect between ¼ and ½ of our clients who file an S corporation tax return! The tax increase would be relatively large for some of our clients. That is best shown with two examples.
I will start with an example of a consulting firm that is owned by a husband and wife who each own 50% of the firm. Let’s say that both the husband and wife work at the firm and that the main asset of the firm is the expertise of the two owners. Let’s say the owners are paying themselves each a salary of $40,000 per year and they are each taking $30,000 per year in profits. Currently they are each paying social security and Medicare taxes on $40,000. If HR 4213 is enacted using the above example they will pay social security and Medicare taxes on $140,000 rather than on $80,000. This will increase their annual self employment taxes by over $9,000 per year!
The next example is a midwife who owns her own business. She works for the firm and is the firm’s only employee. Let’s say she pays herself a salary of $30,000 per year and she takes $20,000 each year in profits. Currently she pays social security and Medicare taxes on $30,000.
If HR 4213 is enacted using the above example she will pay social security and Medicare taxes on $50,000 rather than on $30,000. This will increase her annual self employment taxes by over $3000 per year!
We will monitor this bill as it progresses to keep you “in the loop”. The bill will not affect anyone this year.
We believe this provision is unfair to small businesses because it will force certain small business owners to pay more in taxes than their larger competitors.
The best way to stop this bill is to contact Senator Evan Bayh and Senator Richard Luger!
SBS CPA Group